Plaintiff Cannot Overcome Adversity


Definition of tragedy includes:

A serious drama describing a conflict between a (hero) and a superior force and having a sorrowful conclusion that elicits pity or terror. (Webster)

This definition stems from Aristotle and Poetics. Aristotle teaches in tragedy at the highest level the plot controls the hero. The tragic plot must concern a universal truth that is greater than the hero. The audience knowing the universe in sequences of cause and effect sees in tragedy the hero must and will succumb to the adversity. The hero either does not recognize the adversity is greater than her or refuses to recognize it is greater. Either way the audience knows the adversity is too great to overcome. Audience members feel pity for the hero and fear the adversity could happen to them.

To have a personal injury tragedy-a case worthy of trial- the plaintiff must have permanent injury. Permanent injury is the adversity plaintiff cannot overcome. Although plaintiff may not admit to inability to overcome, the jury knows she will never overcome the injury.

The jury knows they have the ability and the duty to do the only thing they can  to remedy the adversity- provide fair compensation. When the jury sees an honest true to life person, who has been dealt adversity, who does everything in her power to overcome, but no matter how hard she tries she is a victim of fate beyond her control, the jury  sees the tragedy and will likely respond with fair compensation.

    30 Responses to “Plaintiff Cannot Overcome Adversity”

    1. […] Plaintiff Cannot Overcome Adversity | Zen Lawyer Seattle […]

    2. […] Plaintiff Cannot Overcome Adversity | Zen Lawyer Seattle […]

    3. […] Plaintiff Cannot Overcome Adversity | Zen Lawyer Seattle […]

    4. […] Plaintiff Cannot Overcome Adversity | Zen Lawyer Seattle […]

    5. Your input into my blog makes this community a better place to be.

    6. Would it be ok to use your RSS for my site?

    7. dentists in coney island says:

      I usually dont take time to ever make comments on a blog but I gotta to say I would really be doing you a grave disservice if I didnt write something. This post has most definitely shown me the light. Thank you so much for creating it.

    8. Chauncey Colosi says:

      I’d like to say – thank you for this!

    9. doctor phillip says:

      great article, how do you feel this will be affected in the future? I’m glad I stumbled across this website!

    10. Gil Spillane says:

      I feel like I’m often looking for interesting things to read about a variety of topics, but I manage to include your blog among my reads because you have entries that I look forward to.

    11. Judge Judy–Plaintiff Sues Online says:

      […] Plaintiff Cannot Overcome Adversity | Zen Lawyer Seattle […]

    12. I happened to stumble across this website searching for something different, glad I stumbled into it though. Very interesting.

    13. mesothelioma says:

      Super informative article, thanks a million.

    14. Amanda Lee says:

      True, but interesting, as are many of your pages. I read through the archives over the past week, and I must say I think I’m infatuated.

    15. John Talalay says:

      Amazing! Thank you!

    16. Claretha Dicorcia says:

      Amazing POST! 😀

    17. Roscoe Bohl says:

      This post seems to be miraculous. I will perfectly utilize this post for my work and would be very

    18. This was very clear, to the point and well written. I’m going to bookmark this for later reference. Best of luck to you.

    19. Andree Tromley says:

      Very Imformative!

    20. Thresa Faulconer says:

      If you really want you can look the other way and not talk about it. The real truth comes with being honest with yourself and your goals. Generally this will lead to a mistaken and unproductive life.

    21. Well written article, well investigated and useable for me in the future. I am happy you took the time and effort to make this posting. Will be back soon.

    22. Keep up good work,very good article.

    23. Era Tavolieri says:

      I’m still learning from you, but I’m making my way to the top as well. I absolutely enjoy reading everything that is written on your website. Keep the articles coming. I loved it.

    24. I adore your style about Plaintiff Cannot Overcome Adversity | Zen Lawyer Seattle

    25. Lady Goodnow says:

      This is really interesting. Thanks for posting it. By the looks of the comments, many others think so too.

    26. Cal Grant says:

      Finally, an issue that I am passionate about. I have looked for information of this caliber for the last several hours. Your site is greatly appreciated.

    Leave a Reply